Table of Contents

August Articles Online

About Grapevine

Vol. 62 No. 4

The Perfect Meeting
A speaker asks what an AA's got to lose by drinking, and gets an answer he'll never forget

At only eight months sober, I had been elected secretary of my home group, a most important and noteworthy position. It’s important, for it is really the secretary’s meeting — he or she does all the work to keep it going and interesting. To top things off, I had, all on my own mind you, managed to obtain a most popular speaker. I had already chosen a super topic, and was sure they were all going to say, “Thanks, Grégoire. Thanks to you this is a truly great meeting.”

“My” meeting started off fine, on time, like it should, in the church basement. I sure was proud of myself.

The meeting approached half-time. Most of the people who commented on the speaker’s fine talk, the “format,” knew me. I recognized them and allowed them to speak, knowing they would have good comments to make.

Even the topic I had “suggested” was met with great approval — it was most unusual, no one had ever thought of it; why, it wasn’t even in the Big Book, nor thought up by Bill W. or any of the old-timers. All right, here it is: What would you lose if, after your time so far in AA, you decided to pick up just one drink? Yes, it was unusual, even startling, I might add, and it just “came to me.” Would you call that “inspired”? Wow!

Then came the tragedy.

I would never have anticipated it. Some bum had been let into my meeting. Well, he was sober I guess, but look at him! — in rags, a disgrace.  How awful. And they let him in! To “my” meeting.

Oh, horror of horrors, he had his hand up. What nerve! He wanted to speak at my meeting. Well, not to worry, he will be ignored, I thought. Still,  his hand was up, and after everyone had said good, appropriate things in response to my unusual question. Oh well, let him speak. What can he possibly say that might spoil my meeting?

The old bum cleared his throat and started to speak: “You ask what I would lose, if after all I have learned in AA this past year, I now would pick up just one drink?”

“Well,” he said, “I would lose, most of all, my dignity as a man.” There was silence. I don’t even remember the meeting ending, the clearing up, people getting their coats and leaving.

I sat silent in my secretary chair. Did  I imagine the chair had shrunken in size? The old man was the last to leave, and suddenly I heard my voice calling to him: “Thank you, brother.” I was shaking now, but blurted out: “Thank you for what you said.” Silently, slowly, I put on my coat and held the door open for this old man who had . . . dignity — a concept I hadn’t understood until then and didn’t realize I would find at this “perfect” meeting.

Grégoire G.
San Francisco, California